Vias directly on SMD pads?

In certain high-performance or high-density PCB designs, you might encounter the need to place vias directly on surface-mount device (SMD) pads. This technique, often called "via-in-pad," has both advantages and challenges. Here’s an in-depth look at the practice:

Benefits of Via-in-Pad

  1. Reduced Inductance:

    • Explanation: By placing vias directly on SMD pads, the connection to the internal layers or ground plane is shortened.
    • Impact: This reduces the trace length and thereby minimizes the inductance, which is particularly beneficial in high-speed designs [citation:1].

  2. Enhanced Signal Integrity:

    • Explanation: Direct via placement helps in maintaining impedance control and reduces the possibility of creating stubs.
    • Impact: It improves signal integrity by reducing reflections and signal loss [citation:1].

  3. Space Optimization:

    • Explanation: For designs with a high component density or very compact layouts, via-in-pad helps save space.
    • Impact: This is crucial in miniaturized devices like mobile phones and other portable electronics where board real estate is limited [citation:1].

Challenges and Considerations

  1. Solder Wicking:

    • Explanation: One significant challenge with vias in pads is the potential for solder to wick into the via during the reflow soldering process.
    • Impact: This can cause insufficient solder on the pad, leading to poor mechanical and electrical connections [citation:3].

  2. Manufacturing Complexity:

    • Explanation: The process requires precise control during manufacturing to prevent defects.
    • Impact: Via-in-pad designs may necessitate additional processes such as via filling and capping, adding to the manufacturing complexity and cost [citation:2].

  3. Thermal Issues:

    • Explanation: Vias can act as thermal conductors, which might lead to unwanted heat flow away from or to the SMD pad.
    • Impact: This can affect the thermal management of high-power devices and needs careful consideration in thermal design [citation:2].

  4. Reliability Concerns:

    • Explanation: There are concerns about the mechanical and thermal reliability of vias placed in SMD pads, especially under thermal cycling conditions.
    • Impact: The risk is that such vias can cause pads to detach from the PCB due to differential expansion or contraction stresses [citation:2].

Mitigation Techniques

  1. Via Filling and Capping:

    • Explanation: Fill the vias with conductive or non-conductive material and cap them with copper during fabrication.
    • Impact: This process helps prevent solder wicking and ensures a flat surface for component placement and soldering [citation:2].

  2. Solder Mask Plugging:

    • Explanation: Using solder mask to plug the via can reduce the risk of solder wicking.
    • Impact: This provides a similar benefit as via filling in terms of maintaining solder integrity and preventing voids [citation:3].

  3. Thermal Via Placement:

    • Explanation: Strategically placing thermal vias in non-critical regions around the pad rather than directly in the pad.
    • Impact: This balances the need for thermal management and the mechanical reliability of the pad [citation:2].

Via-in-pad designs provide significant performance benefits but must be carefully executed to avoid reliability issues. With appropriate manufacturing techniques and design considerations, these challenges can be mitigated, allowing designers to take full advantage of the benefits offered by this approach [citation:1][citation:2][citation:3].

Back to Lisa's Column